Steve: I feel the need to go watch some good sci-fi movies.
Joe: Like Battlefield Earth?
Steve: Which will be hard because frankly, there are so few in the world.
Joe: Oh wait, there it is.
Worst film of the 2000′s, Battlefield Earth.
Steve: Okay, that’s a conversation we can have:
Sci-fi movies that are actually, truly GOOD.
Go.
Joe: Matrix 1.
Steve: First three Star Wars movies.
Joe: …..
Steve: Serenity.
Joe: Right.
Couldn’t remember the name.
I was going to call it Firefly.
Steve: Star Trek 2, 6 and First Contact.
And I liked 3.
1 has its place but let’s leave it off the the list.
Uh…
Are we out already?
Joe: Was the Prestige sci-fi?
I don’t think so.
Steve: No.
I can list some that other people might say but I hated.
Alien. Blade Runner.
Joe: Look at this list. Confusing.
http://www.imdb.com/chart/sci-fi
They have “The Thing” on there, which is more horror than sci-fi.
Steve: Oh Terminator.
Joe: Terminator.
Steve: I think of that more as an action movie though.
It really only had the one sci-fi element.
Joe: E.T.
Steve: E.T., yeah.
Joe: Yeah, it’s a really thin list.
And no series survived unscathed.
Half the Star Wars blow.
2/3 of Matrix films suck.
Steve: More than half of the Star Treks blow but I still love them.
Joe: They have Back to the Future on there.
Back to the Future?
Sci-fi?
Steve: Oh yeah, forgot to mention. The new Star Trek is good.
BttF is sci-fi.
It’s sci-fi comedy, but it still counts.
The Iron Giant.
Joe: ….I guess those should all be on there though.
I’m not the biggest Iron Giant fan.
Steve: Yeah.
Man it’s amazing how many movies can be counted as sci-fi that I wasn’t even thinking of.
Joe: I know.
Children of Men, which is amazing.
It’s sci-fi, but barely
Steve: Children of Men definitely isn’t sci-fi.
It’s set slightly in the future, but that doesn’t make it sci-fi.
Joe: Yeah.
Steve: It’s just drama/psychological horror.
Joe: Their list is confusing.
Hold on one second, let me go check my DVD’s to see what I’m missing.
Steve: Ok.
You’re going to come back and say Total Recall.
And I’m going to disagree with you.
Because if you had left that movie here when you moved out, I would have either thrown it away or mailed it back to you.
Joe: No.
I knew you wouldn’t agree.
The only film that might be sci-fi, but really isn’t, that we haven’t mentioned is Hellboy.
But that’s more “spiritual fiction” than science fiction.
Steve: That’s fantasy.
Joe: It may have created its own genre, if it wasn’t already a comic book.
Steve: Sci-fi is technically a sub-genre of fantasy, but Hellboy isn’t sci-fi.
Joe: There are scientific elements of it, but really it’s not sci-fi.
Steve: Hellboy is very clearly urban fantasy.
It’s distinctive, but it did not create a new genre.
Joe: I know, I was just grasping at straws for potential films we’ve forgotten.
Steve: Now that I’m writing a fantasy novel I’ve developed very strong opinions about the classifications of fantasy sub-genres.
But I’m afraid I still don’t know if my own book is high fantasy or low fantasy.
Joe: 12 Monkeys is sci-fi.
In the future and deals with time travel.
Steve: 12 Monkeys yes.
Joe: And it’s really good
Steve: Yeah.
Joe: Okay, this list makes me angry.
http://www.sci-fimoviepage.com/art_8.html
Steve: When I started this conversation though I was just thinking of spaceship movies.
Now that I think about what else the genre involves I wish to retract my earlier statement that there are very few good movies.
Instead let’s list good spaceship movies.
Joe: Oh
Independence Day.
The Star Trek films you mentioned.
The first three Star Wars.
Steve: 2001, original Star Wars trilogy, Serenity, and a few of the Star Treks.
Anything else?
Joe: Trying to think.
But, I don’t think so
Steve: Yeah, see.
Joe: Gattica had a space ship in the last shot?
Steve: Space Opera
That’s the phrase I was looking for.
Joe: Oh.
Steve: That’s the name of the sub-genre.
Independence Day isn’t one because it all takes place on Earth.
Joe: You know what film I liked, but that gets no play?
Event Horizon.
Best sci-fi spaceship movie since….
Steve: Yeah, that was good.
I agree that it is sorely shafted as both a sci-fi movie and a horror movie.
There have been several kick-ass video games that have been space operas lately.
But few movies.
Joe: You know what the best sci-fi film of the 2000′s is when it comes right down to it?
Steve: Joe’s Mom Does Argos VII?
Joe: Battlestar Galactica is a 70 hour sci-fi movie.
Steve: Eh.
Joe: It filled the sci-fi gap very well while it was in existence.
Steve: We’re gonna avoid that conversation by saying it doesn’t qualify as a movie.
Joe: I agree, but you see my point.
I think part of the reason good films get made is because there’s a need, and with BG, there was a need for quality sci-fi.
Steve: Yeah, but the truth is I just recently got around to borrowing the first season of that show from my father-in-law.
I’ve only watched the opening 3-hour miniseries so far and I’m not enjoying myself nearly as much as I’d hoped.
There are a lot of factors that may have contributed to that though, so the jury’s still out.
Joe: Well, you’re sad.
Steve: I am going to keep watching. But I’m not sure I’m going to become a BG fan.
Joe: You don’t have to. We don’t need you.
Steve: Part of the problem was I lived with you.
So there were a bunch of things I knew were going to happen before they did and that might have ruined some of the experience.
Another big one was that I didn’t know I was getting into a three-hour miniseries with no breaks when I put the DVD in and pressed play.
Joe: Ah.
Steve: So it really became a chore to finish.
Joe: I understand.
You’ve got to know what you’re getting into.
We forgot Men in Black. The first one, which is spaceships and sci-fi.
And funny.
And Will Smith.
And Tommy Lee Jones.
And aliens.
And killing bugs.
Steve: Yeah, MiB rules
Joe: I think what frustrates me about Will Smith is that as a sci-fi fan, I get a lot of him, and much of it sucks.
Although, that’s not really his fault.
I Robot was poor
MiB 2 was sucky.
Steve: MiB two sucks to almost the exact opposite degree that MiB 1 ruled
Joe: Addendum:
Cocoon.
Sci-fi movie, has Wilford Brimley.
Steve: Oh yeah.
Joe: He’s the white James Earl Jones.
Top ten reason I love Wilford Brimley;
1. He’s PRO-cock fighting.
2. He was a body guard to Howard Hughes.
Steve: That’s only two.
Joe: Actually, there’s only one reason I like Wilford Brimley – he’s PRO cock fighting.
If the first one is “supports cock fights” you don’t need the other nine.
Steve: True.
http://www.theonion.com/content/node/36292
Addendum
Steve: I can’t BELIEVE we forgot to mention Sunshine. Sunshine rocks the house.